I will only buy a game I can play and resell if it costs $70.
Because they aren’t “physical copies”. The industry killed that off, but they’re leaving boxes out for those trying to support it.
Such things should have also killed off the concept or preordering, and yet, it persists.
Solution: STOP FUCKING BUYING SHIT FROM COMPANIES SPITTING IN YOUR FACE. Please.
lol “physical copies?” You mean your empty plastic box with a download code?
I did hear you could literally hold the box up to the light and read the code inside yesterday. I am guessing that’s actually true. Which is hilarious. Think I might go down to Walmart and see if I can get a free game code.
Why wouldn’t the code require purchase? Ah, this is a gift card scam. They nabbed the code, waited for it to be purchased, then activated it? Wouldn’t the thief need to know when it was purchased and before the purchasee got home?
see the code through the box
If it does work, other people have probably already stole these codes before you.
Not a problem. I’ll just need to have a friend watch for store employees while I relieve my town of their entire supply of GTA VI codes.
Shoplifting has never been easier.
Aren’t the games locked up?
Not at the one nearest me. They have a cabinet but it has no doors.
As I understand it, there was a poster in the way of doing that, but some person on tiktok or some other variant did it after removing the poster to freak people out.
Now I understand why everyone wants “physical games”. They think that means a fucking box and not the actual full content of an application. So Its a “physical copy” if you pay for a plastic case that holds a card with a number on it.
That to say, we will never see a “physical copy” anymore with any AAA titles since they’re too big to store on any consumer grade optical media.
It doesn’t have to be optical media. They could do like Nintendo and bring the cartridge back.
Aren’t Switch cartridges basically memory cards? It’s nice because the games I have on cartridge don’t take much space on the console itself. Also, if it’s not read-only it means you can update it too
I’ll defend the technicality that most games aren’t playable solely off of disk these days, but yeah having a physical token of the ownership of a licence is fuckin invaluable apparently.
“Please swap to disk 44”
As far as I can tell Sony deliberately stopped research into optical discs ten years ago. UHD was launched in 2016 and can store 100Gb. GTA6 could have been a two-discer with a bit of judicious compression and trimming.
I miss installing most wanted off of 4 cds. Those were the days.
I got you beat… windows 98r2 was 30 floppies iirc
The disc itself is functionally useless. But the physical ownership aspect is easily replaced.
Just use a USB drive as the physical license token instead of the disc. No need to store the full game on it, just use a few MB of cheap Read-Only Memory.
Every game requires Day 1 patches to be playable anyway, so the disc never let you play the game on its own anyway, and after the install is only ever used as a license already. Why even pretend the game is actually there and useable?
I’m sorry. if a game can’t fit on a 50gb disc, I don’t want it.
K. Too bad a lot of games are bigger than that.
they are?
the biggest game I’ve got installed is like 12gb. guess I don’t play AAA games.
They are, and most of the idiots complaining about physical copies are talking about games that would never fit on optical media in the first place, which is what they are mad are being removed, which also have not recently had all the files necessary for said games to be stored on in the first place, hence the entire complaint is fundamentally childish.
And at the end of the day even if an entire game is stored on a bespoke flash drive, there is no way to say that bespoke storage will continue to function forever. But most people just get mad when they read “no more disk drive so you don’t own game anymore because no more disk drive.”
you know you can have multiple discs right? in fact it used to be pretty common for games to come on multiple discs.
And BDXL gets up to 128GB for a single-sided disc. Which will fit the vast majority of games. Only a handful of relatively recent games exceed that.
I think games should switch to USB thumb drives for physical copies. Publishers should get creative and put the drive in a figurine like an amiibo to sell multiples of the same game with different character figurines and players can collect them.
So you can play offline??? Hahahahahaha
No.So we’re going back to cartridges? I’m cool with that.
Please make it PCIe though.
In this memory price economy?
No. Not unless you want to buy a new copy every time you go to reinstall it.
flash memory is not an archival storage medium.
There is a strong chance it will self erase, if not the drive become completely non-functional, by the time you come back to reinstall it (or possibly when you first install it after getting home, if its been out a while and sitting on a shelf).
meanwhile, even haphazardly stored pressed optical media can last muiltiple decades. Even burned optical media, which has a much shorter life than pressed manufactured disks, has a longer expected functional life.
Well with the current NAND shortage those would cost about 500$ each or something
Not if you don’t care about putting the game on the drive. It’s already obsolete by the time the user gets the game box, and they always require Day 1 patches to be functional anyway. Just ignore needing to include the game on the stick entirely. Enough space for a license key would only need a few MB, and it doesn’t need to be particularly robust stuff either, it could be permanently read-only.
Use the USB stick as a physical license key/token. Because nothing is actually run from the discs anyway once installed, the system already checks for a corresponding disc, then it looks for a stored license on the console, and if one is missing it checks the user’s account for a license. So you just adjust that first physical check to look for either the corresponding disc or USB key.
the whole “ship it broken and patch it later” bullshit only started with the always online internet connected era.
Games were capable of being shipped, without being patched, for far longer than that, and rarely had any game breaking bugs.
Doesn’t really matter when it started, that was 20 years ago. It’s here and it’s never going away. Complaining about it is a waste of time and energy that’s much more useful handling new issues you can still effect.
The problem with the license key dongle idea is that it projects outside the device, and it could lead to damage by younger ones. It could be a micro usb dongle encased in a figurine or something, which could add to the release collectible, and it could “snap off” if clipped by kids running around being stupid.
The problem with the license key dongle idea is that it projects outside the device, and it could lead to damage by younger ones.
You could say the same about controller wires or even memory cards on previous consoles. That’s not a very good excuse.
It’s as big or small as you want to make it. There are a ton of tiny USB dongles that are a fraction of an inch long. Basically every wireless keyboard, mouse, and controller that use a 2,4GHz signal (not bluetooth) come with a tiny dongle like this now.
https://media.piefed.social/posts/l7/fO/l7fOxnBa5Ud4hWO.png
Even smaller potentially if they want to use USB-C instead of USB-A ports. If they choose to make them bigger or more complicated for sales or collectibles, that’s a possibility. But strictly as a replacement for disc licenses, nothing bigger than that is needed, maybe just a bit more to show the box art or something. Heck, they could even allow it plug into the controller charging port.
That entirely defeats the purpose of physical media imo. But then I haven’t used a console since the PS3 so I’m not exactly the target audience here.
That entirely defeats the purpose of physical media imo.
How so? The info on the disc now doesn’t let you play the game anyway. At most, it makes the initial download and install take a little less time.
Take a brand new PS5, pop the disc in with no internet connection, and you still can’t play the game because it needs at least a day 1 patch to enable it to work anyway. Why even pretend a playable game is actually there? The disc is just a license already.
This is on purpose so they can gatekeep computing and keep it being hyper capitalistic instead of letting it get more left wing like open source was threatening
You are both right. There currently is no good way out of this mess other than trying to keep together what we already own somehow. And only installing DRM free software on those drives. Or, you know, software that was made DRM free by Good Samaritans.
I like this idea, but it has a practical issue in terms of USB throughput. Not all ports ok your machine are created equal, and that could cause some issues for some people.
Definitely a solvable problem, but it would slow adoption of this method.
I like this idea, but it has a practical issue in terms of USB throughput
Only if you put the actual game on it, which is never really used anyway now.
Every game has a required day 1 patch, so you just make the USB key a physical license/token the same way the disc is, and then have it download the game when plugged in, it’s going to have to download updates to play anyway no matter what.
Then you can sell the USB the same way you sell discs now. Minimal storage space since it only needs to hold the license not the actual game.
How so? Consoles are standardized and with USB-C and whatever the fastest usb 4 standard is, that should not be a problem with pulling game assets (or at least the most important one) from the stick.
What I rather see: 128/256GB M.2 SSD QLC cartridges.
Essentially Xbox already does it with those small external modules which Sony solved with standard internal M.2 instead.
that’s a great idea…except AI has taken all the nand flash.
That’s what the switch uses basically.
Good idea. Also, hush, they can hear you and my wallet is already weeping
Grand theft gamo
/thread
“copies”, “physical”.
I miss the CD Rom drive.
There were already articles a few days ago about how you could read the product code through the box in certain countries by simply shining a flashlight through it, because the regional distributor cheaped out on the paper inset that would have prevented it.
I’m sure making that knowledge public helped the situation. /s
Does that mean that the code can only be used once?
So for instance buying the « physical » version of the game doesn’t allow you to resell it?
Correct.
The physical version is just a glorified collector’s set, even the physical box only gives you the digital version.
Correction: the actual collector’s set doesn’t actually come with the game, digital or physical.
Once again advocating for one of the few ways we can exercise power here: Stop buying their bullshit.
Hahahaha
Sorry for the useless comment but a regular upvote didn’t feel like enough
It’s sadly not the first time this is a thing. There have been several “collectors editions” that didn’t include the game throughout the years. It’s so fucked.
So, it does kinda make sense. It means R* doesn’t have to make a bunch of different collectors sets, instead they make one and you buy your choice of game in your region. I also don’t doubt R* would’ve charged $100 more for including the game anyways.
Exactly what I’d expect, as someone who occasionally plays a video game 😅
lol, wtf is even going on anymore
I had thought that you would be at least able to resell the code and transfer the licence to someone else…
That’s crazy…
The game looks and sounds great, bit so many things aemre pushing me away from it…
Aha why would you think that at all? The game companies have already been burned multiple times trying to speed up the death of physical media so they should kill the secondary market.
A good compromise would be allowing the code to work multiple times but only be installed on one system at a time. This would introduce other issues though as people could cycle through all the number combinations and eventually figure out what codes work and ‘steal’ those games.
You’re missing the point.
You’re assuming these gaming companies care about their users…
It’s like my copy of wow I purchased 20 years ago. I have the box and game, but seems my account has disappeared and I’d need to repurchase
Oh I definitely get why they do it, but claiming it’s a cost issue to print all these disks doesn’t make sense when they could implement a similar mechanism with digital-only games. They of course don’t want to because they want to wipe out the second-hand market but pointing stuff out like this leaves them nothing to hide behind.
That would require an online connection to verify whether that license is still “valid” every time you open the game to ensure it hasn’t been installed another system since it was last used, or at least a periodic check-in with an allowed overlap period.
This is exactly what Xbox was eviscerated for back when they first announced the Xbox One.
Understood loud and clear. NFTs for games coming right up.
They may have been eviscerated for it back then but that was over a decade ago and I can’t imagine it would affect that many people now especially in the context of a 200+GB game that’s digital-only to begin with. Back then you could play from disks offline still but that isn’t possible now. I think most people would prefer this to having a game that’s completely worthless and non-transferable the second you play it one time.
Steam and Ninfendo (?) prove it doesn’t need to be every time. Low bar sure, but for lending my friend a game I bought on the eShop it’s still pretty nice.
The Xbox system almost certainly wasn’t going to work that way either. The “always online” requirement was a rumor before it was officially announced, and Microsoft actively denied it. They usually just don’t comment about that stuff when it’s the plan or at least being considered, so an actual denial means it probably wasn’t the actual plan. The announced 24 hour period got it’s deserved backlash, but the solution wasn’t to give it a reasonable timeframe, the hivemind forced it to be scrapped entirely even though most of the plan was fine, useful, and even in use by Steam already.
What Xbox announced officially at E3:
- All games, including those purchased at retail, would be bound to the user’s Xbox Live account. So it didn’t matter if you got a disc or not, a license would be tied to your account.
- Users could access their games from any other Xbox One console by logging in. This is exactly how digital games work everywhere now, and basically always have.
- The disc would not be needed once installed, because the license would be on your account not the disc itself.
- Users could share their games with up to ten designated “family” members. This is basically the same as Steam’s family sharing.
- If a publisher allowed a game to be traded or resold, users could do this at “participating retailers”, and could also transfer a game directly to any Xbox Live friend who had been on their list for at least 30 days, but only once per game. (This was a large complaint for the people that still thought stores like Gamestop giving you $5 for your used disc were relevant still even in 2013, even though they almost certainly would have been one of those authorized companies). Considering the vanishingly small number of people that sold their games then, even fewer now, this was a hilariously overblown response.
- To synchronize licenses, the console would be required to connect to the internet once every 24 hours; if the console could not connect, all games would be disabled until the console was connected again. (People complained about this specific timeframe for poor network connectivity areas, rightfully so, and military personnel. There almost certainly would have been alternate solutions for military to designate those accounts, and probably the entire timeout frame being extended instead of 24 hours honestly but it didn’t stick around long enough).
The hivemind latched onto that 24 hour period and absolutely all of this was scrapped before E3 was over. So Gamestop’s rotting shell could continue to fuck people over even now a decade later as a TEMU gaming paraphernalia clearing house. And sharing your digital games with friends still isn’t a thing for most consoles without a disc despite most purchases being digital anyway. Ironically probably the only pro-consumer thing Nintendo has ever done in it’s video game history.
Even better would be just having a disc.
i still have the pc edition of gta 5 on seven discs. it sounds like gta 6 would have fit comfortably on five blu-rays, but then there goes their excuse to stop you from reselling something you “bought”
That’s kind of what Nintendo did with their new Virtual game cards.
I guess so. Its not the first game having a code in a box. Its similar to a Steam code, that tie to your account and then can never be used again - its consumed, you become a consumer.
This is actually one of the things where Nintendo is ahead, with the game key carts. While its still a code basically, you still own the cartridge and can sell it to others. Microsoft has a new strategy too. You can pop in your disc on the console, then it ties a digital license it to your account. If anyone else pops the disc in, then you loose the digital license. This makes it possible to sell those games, regardless of if is something on the disc or not.
Uh story time! So like 15 years ago, I bought Napoleon Total War. We didn’t have a games shop in town, so I ordered it online. It was supposed to arrive the next day, but delivery got fucked so it took a week to arrive. I was super excited to finally play the game, only to discover the case didn’t have a CD. It turned out it was just a box, with the plastic stuff to hold a CD, but only with a Steam key i instead. I waited a week to get a physical copy of a game, just to get a key I could’ve bought for the same price directly from Steam…
Ugh that sucks! It was so much more fun going into a games store, browsing the shelves and physically buying a copy.
Hell yeah, love story times. :D
That’s basically what happens with GTA 6 too. As long as they are upfront about it and you know about it, its fine. Because that is the “contract”. But if you didn’t know, then it sucks and is not okay. Either you didn’t read the fine print (it shouldn’t be a fine print anyway, but a big disclaimer) or they didn’t mention it (which would be illegal, but how to proof that?). I wonder how many don’t know they purchasing a code only, with GTA 6. I also wonder how many even care.
Back then I didn’t even consider the option. I always bought physical copies, and didn’t use Steam at all. It was probably written somewhere, but even if I’d read it, I probably wouldn’t have connected the dots, because why would you ever just want a useless empty plastic case?
Nintendo is great if you want to buy nothing but sequels of the same game made 30+ years ago
Also, I owned a wii. Guess who basically needs to re buy all the games if I want to use them on switch
My point was, that there are better ways than a code-in-a-box for digital only games.
I think its important that we make this public, because its also to help those in such a situation. I don’t like hiding issues, because that also means anyone having the issue would not know why and can’t even prevent it. Off course, I completely understand the paradoxical situation here, because if you don’t tell it to the mass, then most people won’t abuse it.
Physical copies. Codes. What? This is not a physical copy, then.
“Physical” copies you say? Doesn’t look like it
I can only laugh. This should be pretty easy to get resolved in any country that has consumer protection laws.
“physical copies”
Imagine buying a game without the disc.
So any steam user?
Steam user don’t get tricked by “physical” packaging.
I mean from the perspective of those who play on PS5.
Most PC gamers have been buying games without a disc for over decade now with physical games being relegated to limited releases and the trend has been that way too for consoles for a decade now too.
The only reason this hasn’t been a uproar in the PC community is that the digital storefronts by and large so far haven’t been nearly as anti-consumer as the console market has been with digital licensing and that can change with a single person’s death.
Removing discs from PlayStation is entirely corporate design.
Look at Activision’s decision to have MW2022 only take up 1 gb on the disc, refusing to use all the available Blu-ray space to hold the game forcing players to play the next instalment. Bobby Kotick hated people playing bops2 to this day.
Not everyone wants to march into having everything digital. I’m tired of this bad trend being forced upon everyone ie contactless payments and ebooks.
You’re free to play on GOG if you prefer that. But others like holding the game and having box art. It’s specially insulting on console where you have to pay for multiplayer and the big wigs want to further erode the experience.
I’m not going past WiiU for consoles and the pc will be used for the newer releases.
At least the retro consoles are there for us.



















