I currently work at an “AI First” 🤢 fintech company, and we’re mandated to program agentically. I was fortunate enough to start working before the AI hype, but the environment right now is daunting.
There’s too much unmaintainable code slop and throw away scripts committed that I can’t keep track anymore. Each PR has so much diffs that it feels like someone had diarrhea and shat all over.
I try to manually review the code, but it feels like best effort at most. Like I may only understand 70% of the thing that I’m reviewing. What ends up happening usually is that I just ask the model and verify the output(which is horrifying I know)
I spend the whole day arguing with AI, reviewing, and pushing back against its output that sometimes I wonder if I am the one driving AI or is it driving me.
–
Recently, I noticed that I’ve becoming more reliant on the model and that my skills have been atrophying. What would’ve taken me an afternoon if I program it by hand, would take me a week now if I do it now. I also find my head hurting and myself glossing over the code in code reviews and prompting claude to do even the basic of commands.
I get that there’s more to programming in software engineering (collaboration, dealing with people, etc etc), but I don’t feel like I am in control of the systems I am building anymore with the engineering aspect being replaced with babysitting and self lobotomy.
–
Off work hours, I try to brush up by reading on system design and architecture books, typing by hand if I’m learning a new technology or stack, but I feel like it’s not enough to prevent from skill atrophy.
How are y’all coping and how do you recover from this? I am afraid on what skills that I’ll be able to bring at my next place of employment if I resign and that I’m becoming a jack of all trades master of none type of thing - having only shallow understanding.
That’s the job now. If you need a job you’re going to have to get with the program. If not just quit!
In terms of maintaining skills, I have ~4 hours on a train each week that has shitty WiFi so I can’t use AI there - I spend some of that time doing manual coding on a side project.
I’m lucky enough to work somewhere that doesn’t dictate what tools I have to use. I don’t use it for code, because that’s just not fun for me. But I will use it once in a while when web search just totally fails me, but I know the answer is Out There (in the weights of scraped corpus).
I’m fighting back, I guess, mostly just by showing that it’s easy and enjoyable to do things without checking in with Sam Altman first. ;p
Which skill are you worried about atrophying? Writing code, reading code, or something else?
I find agents very useful for exploring, and understanding existing code bases I am not very familiar with, or if there are time constraints. One thing I have been thinking about, is using agents to assist with creating a plan, but instead of getting an agent to implement that plan, I’d rather make the code changes myself.
Another way could be regularly doing exercises at Exercism.
Personal projects done without AI. It’s like artisanal coding. People will pay tons of money for it one day. We will be able to sit in museums implementing simple scripts without AI so kids on school trips can see how human brain works without assistance. Of course the AI will have to explain to them what’s happening.
People will pay tons of money for it one day.
I hate to say it, but this sounds like copium. Do you still see loads of well-paid furniture woodworkers? Nah, it’s all replaced with factory IKEA stuff. Sorry, but nobody will pay for “artisanal coding” when they can get whatever they need from the AI for free.
But they will organize school trips to see us in museums, right?
(in case it’s not obvious enough, I was joking)
Loads? No, but the ones who do good work are well compensated. Just need rich clients.
… using small words.
I don’t know but I’m in the same boat except its just killing all of my motivation. I really love software but not like this and it’s making me want to switch fields
I can relate, but there are still oases of sanity out there. Very hard to find anywhere profit motive is worshiped over common sense, though.
Can relate
which other fields have you found not related to CS
Maybe electrician? I don’t know if that field is even safe though excluding the hands on parts. I have been finding I’m leaning more into server hardware and networking lately though just for my hobby setup. There’s no AI involved when swapping server components or running SFP+ cables to replace ethernet and it makes me happy
At work? Do what they want you to do I guess. If they are mandating you mass produce slop, do exactly that. I’ve tried fighting against it. There’s nothing you can do when your coworker opens a 785 file PR (not an exaggeration) and it needs to be reviewed today. Your carefully crafted code can never keep up with the constant waterfall of whatever the fuck Claude/ChatGPT/whatever calls acceptable these days.
Your best bet at work is to direct the agents others will use. Use a strict linter. Mandate a strict formatter. Add to the instructions that tests must be written and must pass. Do what you can to force it to emit semi-acceptable code (or fail if it can’t).
Outside of work? What’s a coding agent?
Oh my god, the slop PRs with dozens of files abd tens of thousands of loc are insane.
I don’t even know how to review it.
My answer is usually telling them to go back and rethink the design, LLMs hate well encapsulated modules and they’re very good at spaghettifying your dependencies.
They can do a decent job understand the spaghetti, but they have no concept of what exists that didn’t turn up in the last 5 commits or a list of file names. So they reinvent the wheel every time.
If job wants slop, I just queue up work back to back in the slop generator. While the slop generator is running, I’m reading a book or building something by hand to make sure I stay sharp. If my engineering leadership doesn’t care about quality, then why should I? Give em what they want and take care of your own needs
Yeah, one of my co-workers just plays video games while his bot works away. That’s not my way, but imo, that’s a much better trade than trying to spin between 5 different tasks and toiling harder than you ever did when you had to do it “manually.”
If they want fast and cheap they can have it, but don’t work yourself into a burnout trying to make the output totally slop free.
I don’t know, but I can only say that I share the situation.
I work at a very large company that has pushed Ai. I also have 27 years of professional experience, so I lead position hasn’t changed too much, except reviewing Ai work as well. All your problems sounds like a team issue. People shouldn’t commit things they don’t know how and your commits should be small enough that they are easy to review. I had this issue before Ai. I would tell my team to please make small co.mits because either have to review them. We still do the stuff we enjoy ourselves but use Ai for the coding equivalent of “please read this 200 page document and remove all i stances of dog”. Basically something that requires no skill but an insane amount of time.
That being said, I do worry about the new grads.
People shouldn’t commit things without understanding them, but there’s a lot of pressure on people in some of these shops to push out updates at irresponsible speeds. Management is being flooded with messages about 3x, 5x, and 10x production, and you don’t get that with bottlenecks like “understsanding what you’re releasing”.
In a lot of companies, senior management has lost their minds, and have ben fully committed to the slopocalypse.
It’s the pressure to ship things that gets you.
I took over another guy’s work last week and have spent a whole week fixing issues, but his core work needed to get shipped for a major sales deadline. So I got it out the door.
But now I have to bug fix it back to a real solution that aligns with our long term goals which sucks.
nothing new here
ai is just a different flvor to the same shit sammich
People shouldn’t commit things they don’t know how
I don’t use AI, but I read people saying you lose interest when an AI writes it. You check out. So you have less understanding, and it’s not reasonable to expect people to have the same investment. So I don’t believe it is just a team issue.
your commits should be small enough that they are easy to review
Depends on what’s being asked by higher-ups. If there’s management pressure to commit fast, then, again, it’s not a team issue, unless you’re including management in the team.
My job is 75% maintenance and 25% developing new app features. That 25% is really interesting and is what drew me to my current company, but maintenance is what management cares about most and what our customer service team is constantly pushing us to do.
The problem is that it’s boring and repetitive work. Ever since the company started promoting the use of AI, I’ve been delegating these tedious tasks to agents who work on separate Git worktrees, while I focus on learning new things and implementing them alongside new features that we previously didn’t have the time or budget for. Management is satisfied, and I’m learning a lot thanks to the time I’ve saved. Most importantly, I’m still writing code myself, code that I actually enjoy writing.
I made a horizontal career move and accepted as a trade-off that at this time I won’t write code.
Old company: mildly toxic environment, out of touch CEO, poor leadership. Increasing AI push and wild gaps between different people’s competence. Constant arguing. The dreaded 5k loc generated PRs started appearing. My role: ~5% web programming tasks (that I actually signed up for originally) rest was design, review, and people-related work. I was not a manager. Hated it.
The project: 1 year of goal-oriented homelabbing, from a 50€ raspberry pi to hybrid cloud, gitops, kubernetes, and all the good bleeding edge stuff you need to run your own cloud. Did this completely without AI, built the resume, applied to a few places. Happens that one of the companies was looking for the exact stack I built my homelab around.
New company: Platform team, 90% hands on, competent manager, capped AI budgets, people treat each other respectfully. I quite like it. When I do coding it’s simple enough that it stays manageable even though I ask some bot to write it 90% of the time. It gets the job done, I wasn’t hired to write code anyway.
It’s probably a patch, but I’m hoping to run the wave long enough by this move. For the first time in a couple years I feel clarity. I trust that I’ll be able to pick up programming by hand if needed. Most people are in the same boat anyway, so the expectation won’t be there to perform on a similar level instantly. I trust that my ability to learn new things keeps being valuable.
On my free time I don’t currently write code, non-technical hobbies and maintaining the homelab I conjured eat it up. I don’t mind too much. I have enough interesting stuff to do. I think most of all it’s important that I get to create something. If I’m not exactly paid to do that it’s not the end of the world. Much worse situations exist, I’m still paid similar €€ than in my software position.
Nice story and good on you that your new company respects you. Hard to find a good place these days.
On my free time I don’t currently write code, non-technical hobbies and maintaining the homelab I conjured eat it up.
I should get more non-technical hobbies, especially physical ones… But I’ll be literally sat at my wfh desk typing for work, looking forward to after 17h when I can switch the kvm to writing code for pleasure lol. I do really like programming though. Somehow still not sick of it after all these years.
Where I work we can still push back to big PRs. Our guideline is unchanged that it shouldn’t be more than 700 lines of change. The less the better. With agents it’s even simpler to deny a big PR. A manually written big PR would have meant lots of manual effort in reworking it. With agents I basically just demand the author to tell their agent to split their fucking PR up.
How do you push back if that PR comes from your boss or a more tenured eng
Document it as your groups operating principle and get the team to sign off on it. Point them to the doc.
This is the way. It’s how we got our CTO to stop sshing into pods to yolo his ideas.
Use automation checks. Most platforms allow adding tests for every small thing.
We have post commit hooks for agents as well as merge protection based on stuff like what you said
I am a Staff Engineer. So I am high enough in the chain to even close PRs at will.
Other engineers are encouraged to reach out to us staff engineers if they feel powerless on their own.
We can only do our best to not end up with a culture where people fear each other.
Here they just say “ohno so much effort, i already split it in 4, no use in split for the sake of splitting”
Same boat. I’m not even really reviewing the diarrhea code. I just tell the bot to review it. I don’t care. Let it explode. It’s the only way they’ll learn.
I’m also not even paying attention to the implementation tickets. Just tell bot to do it. Whatever.
I’m super checked out at work now. They want me to use AI. Fine. I’m not babysitting it though. If it blows up, it blows up.
Could one simply write code themselves and ask the AI to make it look like it did it?
Simple. My job currently being full-time unemployment.
wish we had UBI






