Dozens of people were arrested in New York City while protesting against Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s participation in the United Nations General Assembly on Thursday.
Actors Susan Sarandon and Hannah Einbinder, as well as activist and whistleblower Chelsea Manning, were among the protesters arrested during a sit-in that blocked a main road leading to the UN.
Handcuffed and escorted by a New York Police Department (NYPD) officer, Einbinder was recorded in a video shared on social media saying, “Netanyahu out of New York, no bombs on Lebanon, no bombs on Iran, stop the genocide.”
Nerdeen Kiswani, founder of Within Our Lifetime, a Palestinian-led community organisation, criticised Mamdani’s video, saying it was “a far cry from campaigning on arresting Netanyahu. Instead of arresting Netanyahu, the NYPD arrested the protesters.
“This is the exact opposite of what Mamdani ran on,” she wrote.
If Mamdani unilaterally orders the arrest of Netanyahu, America would invade New York.
True but what forces him to arrest protesters?
He didn’t arrest protestors. The pigs did, and the pigs needed to be there regardless for the security of the hundreds of other diplomats, many of whom are against Netanyahu and Israel.
Don’t they answer to the mayor at the end of the day?
Your comment reminds me of the people who criticize a bare majority leader of acting like a dictator. Mamdani didn’t wave a magic wand that was able to suddenly replace how every single police department ran things the moment he was elected, just like there are plenty of state law enforcement agencies kneeling to federal orders when they should be heeding state orders. They also weren’t arrested for protesting Netanyahu, they were arrested for blocking a main road into the UN.
I really don’t see how pressuring the police to use less violent tactics is acting like a dictator. I mean I get what you’re saying but what other democratic lever do people have to change the behavior of the police other than the mayor’s office? Maybe ideally they should be under independent democratic control but that’s not the world we live in.
Spoken like someone who doesn’t know how city government works. The mayor isn’t their boss and he has no direct control over any officers beyomd something like declaring an emergency. That would be a bad thing.
I work in municipal government, and it’s a very good thing that the politicians can’t fire me when their Karen friends call. The mayor and Council hire specific high-level people like the City Manager and the municipal judge, and nobody else.
Nypd is a roving gang of criminals answering to no one
That’s all police. Literally that’s how they started
By the end of the day those people have already been arrested. Only thing that can be done, really, would be going forward, but just like the federal government not following the law, we need enforcement mechanisms to make things happen that are against the wishes of the people doing said things. And we really don’t have that right now, when the enforcement are the ones we are trying to restrain.
I dont see the pig union bowing to mamdani’s office without a fight every single time. Not in this climate at least.
Love to be proven wrong.
You arent supposed to have any impact while protesting. Get your permit and sit quietly far far away on your designated street so you don’t bother your betters.
Nerdeen Kiswani, founder of Within Our Lifetime, a Palestinian-led community organisation, criticised Mamdani’s video, saying it was “a far cry from campaigning on arresting Netanyahu. Instead of arresting Netanyahu, the NYPD arrested the protesters.
While I agree with them that Netanyahu should be arrested, neither Mamdani nor the NYPD have the jurisdiction to do it.
They do. Trump can release Netanyahu shortly after but Mamdani has the jurisdiction to make the initial arrest for Netanyahu killing Americans.
This is false. Delete your post, and stop spreading misinformation. I want Netanyahu to rot as much as anyone else, but since he was in NYC for the UN, he has diplomatic immunity. Otherwise every UN meeting would be a free for all.
Do you think the US should’ve been able to arrest Fidel Castro when he stayed in Harlem? Probably not. Diplomatic immunity is the reason why, and it protects people we like, as much as it protects people we don’t.
That is false
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peremptory_norm
A peremptory norm (also called jus cogens)[1] is a fundamental rule of international law that is accepted and recognized by the international community of states as a whole as a norm from which no derogation is permitted. Unlike ordinary treaty obligations or customary international law, a peremptory norm cannot be overridden by treaties, agreements, or national laws. Thought to be so fundamental that it even invalidates rules drawn from treaty or custom, “norms of this character, therefore, cannot be derogated from by the will of the contracting parties.”[2]
There is no universal agreement regarding precisely which norms are jus cogens nor how a norm reaches that status, but it is generally accepted that jus cogens bans genocide, maritime piracy, enslaving in general (i.e. slavery as well as slave trade), wars of aggression and territorial aggrandizement, and generally as well torture, and refoulement.[3]
Unfortunately I don’t think you are correct here. By being a diplomat attached to the UN Netanyahu would have diplomatic immunity while on an official visit. If he had gone to Times Square or something completely outside of the duties of his visit then there might be a case but he didn’t.
Contrary to popular opinion, diplomatic immunity is anything but absolute. It does massively hinder investigations for full diplomats as all their communications etc. are protected. But in most countries they do not have immunity from the law except in matters that pertain to their diplomatic duties.
That is false
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peremptory_norm
A peremptory norm (also called jus cogens)[1] is a fundamental rule of international law that is accepted and recognized by the international community of states as a whole as a norm from which no derogation is permitted. Unlike ordinary treaty obligations or customary international law, a peremptory norm cannot be overridden by treaties, agreements, or national laws. Thought to be so fundamental that it even invalidates rules drawn from treaty or custom, “norms of this character, therefore, cannot be derogated from by the will of the contracting parties.”[2]
There is no universal agreement regarding precisely which norms are jus cogens nor how a norm reaches that status, but it is generally accepted that jus cogens bans genocide, maritime piracy, enslaving in general (i.e. slavery as well as slave trade), wars of aggression and territorial aggrandizement, and generally as well torture, and refoulement.[3]
He has a solid case to argue he does and he never provided the reason he doesn’t. Sounds to me like he doesn’t wanna.
New York City shouldn’t arrest anyone for crimes committed entirely elsewhere absent an extradition request.
New York State shouldn’t arrest foreign diplomats since the federal government is responsible for interacting with diplomats.
The USA shouldn’t arrest any diplomat heading to the United Nations since the UN stops being useful if it’s not a place for hated enemies to talk
The only entity that should be expected to arrest someone at the UN for an ICC warrant is the UN itself. And they fucking should have, but that’s on them and not Mamdani, Hochul, or (sigh) Trump.
He didn’t have the jurisdiction, he asked and checked before, last time Bibi was here
As much as I hate making excuses for politicians… Even if Mamdani ordered Netanyahu to be arrested, he’d just be released within two hours, and Mamdani would be the one arrested next. Or dead.
Then don’t campaign on it. Politicians who are are talk and no action are useless against genocide.
Apparently he can arrest people protesting against genocide though.
Who did he arrest? Does he carry handcuffs on him now?
Do you say the same about Trump and ICE?
The mayor of a city cannot order the police department around…
The mayor appoints the police chief of their desire, who can order the PD around.
Zohran chose hardcore Zionist billilonaire Jessica Tisch who was responsible for brutalizing student protesters
When he campaigns on it he is “a superhero who is going to rid the world of evil”, when he doesn’t do it he is “poor little Mamdani who has no power to do anything”. Leftists are just as susceptible to the cult of personality as reactionaries.
That’s because SCOTUS already said. The United States President is immune from prosecution. Look at Naseratu’s motorcade too. He really is our president I guess
The world is upside down.
Nah. This is about par for the course
US is going to be the new Argentina. All the genocidal nationalist leaders and their supporters are going to move here after they get called out in their own countries.
The US is the “real” Argentina… forgot all the Nazi scientists you got working for you?
Unlike Argentina, that’s not a myth lol
We’ve been minting our own fascists since Hitler was a twinkle in his father’s eye
The scientists mostly weren’t the problem. It was all the guys they recruited to start the CIA and FBI, etc that did the real damage. And the Argentina thing wasn’t a myth.
Ah, my bad, I was thinking in total Nazi + Nazi collaborators, the US takes the cake there, but yeah Argentina apparently got a lot of the big nazi bosses, thanks to Peron, despite having a smaller absolute number of nazis compared to the US.
And by myth I was thinking of the whole Hitler in the lighthouse thing lmao
deleted by creator
Can it be the new Venezuela instead?
weak pathetic country, 100% at fault of almost all of the world’s current problems.
“law and order” my witchy ass.
So Mamdani won’t order NYPD to arrest Netanyahu, but either ordered or allowed to occur the arrest of the protestors?
Yes, as always liberals, by any name, will always defend the status quo.
