The chancellor’s strategy of never contradicting the U.S. president in front of the cameras looks humiliating, but he believes he can talk him around on Ukraine and trade.
I’m sick and tired of this 3d chess narrative when it comes to EU leaders. He is not being wise here. He capitulated and betrayed his ally. Then he will go back to Europe and try pretending his some sort of a leader. Try telling people in Spain that it’s ok they have to fight US alone while Merz is silent because Trump will forget soon. What Merz is doing is extremely damaging to the union. Trump may forget about it but Europeans will remember it next time politicians talk about solidarity.
It’s not about 5D Chess at all, in my opinion. We’re unfortunately at a point where decades of inaction and lethargy have left the EU largely dependent on the US for many things, ranging from defense to energy security to digital infrastructure. The hole we dug for ourselves is so deep that confronting the hegemon, the US, is not realistic any time soon. Therefore I believe it’s more about recognising where we have to use our limited ability to resist and where we can get away with nodding along, while knowing that this is bullshit. I believe the threat to Greenland for example was much more concrete and dangerous and rightly led to Europeans using some of their limited ability to resist to put a foot down. This current threat to Spain seems vague and unenforceable, given the structure of the EU. With the realities being as they are it seems unwise to use what little power we have to resist for a pointless threat that will be forgotten in two weeks. The alternative is a head on collision like the one that Zelensky experienced that may not be forgotten.
What the Europeans should have done is to build an independent power base and maintain that, even if it costs effort and money. Unfortunately we didn’t and now we are where we are.
So you are actually saying that this is part of some calculated, long term strategy and not simple ineptitude. And I disagree. Greenland showed that simply standing up to Trump works. Abandoning Spain like that will be very hurtful to EU as a whole. It will give fuel to the anty-EU far-right parties and exacerbate divisions between countries. Sanchez has a very weak position in Spain right now and being abandoned by other leaders like that is definitely not helping. Pretty much everything Merz and other leaders are doing is weakening EU long term for short term gains. Pools are showing most EU citizens disagree with Trump and see US as the enemy now. It’s perfect moment to make a stand a push hard for independence from US but EU is mostly pretending everything is still fine. This is strengthening pro-Trump, Russia backed extremists like Vox and Sfd while weakening the Union as a whole.
You’re right, decades of inaction brought us here and more inaction is not the right strategy now. People like Merz simply can’t do anything else.
No, you seem to be (willingly?) misrepresenting what I’m saying. There is no long term plan. There is no strategy. There simply is a situation in which the actions of Europeans in the past have caught up with Europeans in the present and we are now stuck between a rock we failed to move decades ago and a hard place we built ourselves. What our current crop of “leaders” seems to be doing is (once again) hoping this all blows over in a decade, because we’re all out of other good options. While this is a fatalistic point of view, I believe it is warranted. Building some degree of strategic autonomy will take years, maybe decades. Until then we remain dependent on the hegemon and cannot face it head first on any and every issue. Had we collectively done what le Général had told us to do back in the 1960s, we’d be in a better position, but we didn’t, so we aren’t.
I’m calling “wait and hope it will pass” a strategy. You seem to disagree it’s a “strategy” but you do agree it’s what they are doing and you say it’s warranted.
I’m saying it’s shortsighted and stupid. They do have a choice. When Trump won for the first time 9 (!!!) years ago they should have realized that US is no longer a valid partner. They had 8 years to invest in defense, forge new alliances and protect economy from US influence. Instead they decided wait hoping it will pass. They also have another option now: capitalize on the negative view of US shared by majority of EU citizens and start making though decisions hoping people will understand and accept them. To do this you need to explain what the situation is and what needs to be done. All the far-right parties in EU that celebrated Trump’s second term are vulnerable now. Instead of exploiting this they are still trying to find some middle ground where they can be friendly to USA and promote EU solidarity at the same time. This situation with Spain shows that it doesn’t work. The messaging from EU is the exact opposite of what it should be and I think it’s result of incompetence, not lack of options.
I’m sick and tired of this 3d chess narrative when it comes to EU leaders. He is not being wise here. He capitulated and betrayed his ally. Then he will go back to Europe and try pretending his some sort of a leader. Try telling people in Spain that it’s ok they have to fight US alone while Merz is silent because Trump will forget soon. What Merz is doing is extremely damaging to the union. Trump may forget about it but Europeans will remember it next time politicians talk about solidarity.
It’s not about 5D Chess at all, in my opinion. We’re unfortunately at a point where decades of inaction and lethargy have left the EU largely dependent on the US for many things, ranging from defense to energy security to digital infrastructure. The hole we dug for ourselves is so deep that confronting the hegemon, the US, is not realistic any time soon. Therefore I believe it’s more about recognising where we have to use our limited ability to resist and where we can get away with nodding along, while knowing that this is bullshit. I believe the threat to Greenland for example was much more concrete and dangerous and rightly led to Europeans using some of their limited ability to resist to put a foot down. This current threat to Spain seems vague and unenforceable, given the structure of the EU. With the realities being as they are it seems unwise to use what little power we have to resist for a pointless threat that will be forgotten in two weeks. The alternative is a head on collision like the one that Zelensky experienced that may not be forgotten.
What the Europeans should have done is to build an independent power base and maintain that, even if it costs effort and money. Unfortunately we didn’t and now we are where we are.
So you are actually saying that this is part of some calculated, long term strategy and not simple ineptitude. And I disagree. Greenland showed that simply standing up to Trump works. Abandoning Spain like that will be very hurtful to EU as a whole. It will give fuel to the anty-EU far-right parties and exacerbate divisions between countries. Sanchez has a very weak position in Spain right now and being abandoned by other leaders like that is definitely not helping. Pretty much everything Merz and other leaders are doing is weakening EU long term for short term gains. Pools are showing most EU citizens disagree with Trump and see US as the enemy now. It’s perfect moment to make a stand a push hard for independence from US but EU is mostly pretending everything is still fine. This is strengthening pro-Trump, Russia backed extremists like Vox and Sfd while weakening the Union as a whole.
You’re right, decades of inaction brought us here and more inaction is not the right strategy now. People like Merz simply can’t do anything else.
No, you seem to be (willingly?) misrepresenting what I’m saying. There is no long term plan. There is no strategy. There simply is a situation in which the actions of Europeans in the past have caught up with Europeans in the present and we are now stuck between a rock we failed to move decades ago and a hard place we built ourselves. What our current crop of “leaders” seems to be doing is (once again) hoping this all blows over in a decade, because we’re all out of other good options. While this is a fatalistic point of view, I believe it is warranted. Building some degree of strategic autonomy will take years, maybe decades. Until then we remain dependent on the hegemon and cannot face it head first on any and every issue. Had we collectively done what le Général had told us to do back in the 1960s, we’d be in a better position, but we didn’t, so we aren’t.
I’m calling “wait and hope it will pass” a strategy. You seem to disagree it’s a “strategy” but you do agree it’s what they are doing and you say it’s warranted.
I’m saying it’s shortsighted and stupid. They do have a choice. When Trump won for the first time 9 (!!!) years ago they should have realized that US is no longer a valid partner. They had 8 years to invest in defense, forge new alliances and protect economy from US influence. Instead they decided wait hoping it will pass. They also have another option now: capitalize on the negative view of US shared by majority of EU citizens and start making though decisions hoping people will understand and accept them. To do this you need to explain what the situation is and what needs to be done. All the far-right parties in EU that celebrated Trump’s second term are vulnerable now. Instead of exploiting this they are still trying to find some middle ground where they can be friendly to USA and promote EU solidarity at the same time. This situation with Spain shows that it doesn’t work. The messaging from EU is the exact opposite of what it should be and I think it’s result of incompetence, not lack of options.