I like what Kagi are doing, even though I don’t pay for their search engine. I’ve been enjoying browsing the Kagi Small Web portal recently.
I’ve been a Kagi subscriber for 6 months and this is the first I’m hearing of the small web portal, so thank you!
You can also use marginalia, an open source small web search engine for this :)
Nice! Link for the lazy: https://marginalia-search.com/
isnt it made by the same guy from Kagi?
As best as I can find from websearching there is no relation or shared people between them… 🤷🏻♂️
Do y’all remember StumbleUpon?
What ? This isn’t new. They have had this for years.
New to one in 10k, or whatever (xkcd)
That doesn’t mean invalidate their comment. The title’s claim is false.
The title’s claim is false?
Does Kagi not have a Fediverse Forms search toggle now?
It doesn’t have it “now”, it’s had it for a while. Maybe a better word is “inaccurate”? Saying it’s new is a lie.
It does have it now I just checked. It may have also had it then, but I can’t confirm that. From your testimony, it seems like Kagi both has this toggle now, and had this toggle then
Your reading comprehension skills are not that great, got it. Thanks for letting everyone know.
No, they don’t have it now.
Though they may again by the time your read this.Schrödinger’s Feature!? O.o
In effect, yes.
It’s a joke; Made by your use of a different meaning of “now” than OP used in the title. I was pointing out that your use of “now” is an instantaneous moment, of which there are really countless numbers, between your typing the letters “n” and “w”, if counted in Plank time. And with such a definition, it’s impossible to know if the feature exists at any given “now”, since we can’t possibly agree on or even accurately choose one. So yes, Schrödinger’s Feature now applies.
I was gonna say I thought I remembered seeing that when I used kagi. Is enabling it buried in a settings menu? I don’t recall
Right there under the search bar on my setup at least.
Kagi calls them lenses, and there’s a bunch. You can change the default by selecting the current one (in my case below, “Small Web”)


Came here to say the same.
As a long time user… definitely had it for years.
That’s not new. They’ve had it for a long time now.
If Kagi were Free (as im Free Beer), Libre (as in Free Speech/Freedom) and Open Source, it were perfect.
But not only it’s not open source, but also it’s paid. I ain’t using nothing that isn’t FLOSS.
And they use Yandex as part of their underlying search.
Yea
At this point, I don’t see why that is any worse than using the services of any US-based Big Tech companies. They have the same kind of anti-privacy business model, their local political regimes have both gone off the rails, and law enforcement and intelligence agencies can legally or extra-judicially snoop through collected data without the user ever knowing.
Some of the services provided by Yandex are, quality-wise, decent enough. I personally tend to find their translation service to be as good or better, as compared to similar services, such as Google Translate or DeepL, so it’s usually my API of choice through Mohzi.
For me its not about the quality provided but about not supporting a company located in a questionable country. To me that includes both the US and Russia.
I agree. But that’s why I was wondering why you were singling out Yandex in particular, when Kagi also sources from questionable US companies.
To me, they’re all equally problematic.
deleted by creator
And they apparently contribute to Yandex.
Thought i remembered something problematic
As opposed to what exactly?
This is great. This was one of things that I disliked about Lemmy, as being federated makes it harder to use external search engines.
I think that might be the final thing to make me switch from DDG to Kagi.
It’s too bad they require a subscription. I’ll never use this shit for this reason alone.
This attitude is why the internet is full of ads. Doing shit for free doesn’t happen on an empty stomach. I’d rather pay a fair price for software and services I use. I’m not saying anyone’s pricing is fair, just pointing out I don’t agree with this behavior.
Naah. People actually paying for the subscription what drives it. YouTube was ad free backing the day. And when they allowed adds. It was intentionally to create an annoyance that they cooked profit from- so that when they offered a add free, they could ALSO profit from.
A one time fee, I understand. A monthly rate to use a web browser is shameful.
Most platforms usually start ad free and with no restrictions. That’s how they capture a chunk of the market. Then, once they have an established customer base, they typically introduce ads or a subscription so they can actually pay for the hardware and bandwidth the service runs on.
This is what YouTube, Google, and pretty much everyone did. It’s the standard play book.
One-time fees are not feasible for this type of business model. If the server costs are ongoing, meaning you have to pay for the user’s usage constantly, then you need to either constantly charge them too, take money out of your own pocket to subsidize it, or sell customer data to once again subsidize it. Nothing is free.
A one-time fee would have to be absurdly high (think hundreds of dollars) to take into account multiple years of usage, otherwise it’s too risky and you’re most likely losing money.
This mindset that subscriptions are all evil when hardware and bandwidth are billed to you every month/year is ridiculous.
Kagi at least is honest from the get go and never tried to trick customers into believing their service would be free forever. That’s what’s actually shitty behavior, when companies put out a product that they then enhsittify for the purposes of extracting profit.
Kagi was a subscription from the get go and told you that’s how they pay their bills, and in return you get the service they promised with no compromises. I’m not arguing whether the price is fair, but at least the business model is honest and doesn’t try to take advantage of me and my data.
At least make prices fucking progressive. If you’re under certain poverty threshold, you don’t pay anything. If you’re over that same threshold, you pay an amount equivalent to what you actually have, so if you’re barely over the threshold, then you pay drastically less than the ones that have the more money.
Youtube also didn’t have a subscription option back in the day, and it also limited the length of videos you could upload. Things cost money to run, and something on the scale of Youtube costs a lot of money to run.
Now to be clear, I don’t pay for Youtube or watch ads, but that’s more because I object to directly giving Google my money with how much value they already generate just tracking and selling what browsing habits I am unable to obscure from them. If there was an option to pay Google $5-10 a month with the enforceable assurance that it came with absolutely no personal tracking and data collection, I would strongly consider it.
You would understand a one-time fee for an active, ongoing, online service?? I’m a fucking communist, please don’t make me defend capitalism…
Even back in the day, people would buy versions of software on disks and updates were limited. There’s a reason why the idea of perpetual licenses died hard and fast and every company everywhere either reneged or died.
I pay for Kagi. If they offered a “one-time lifetime purchase” I’d probably just stop because that would be a giant red flashing neon warning sign.
Why don’t you make an alternative without ads or subscriptions? I’d love to use a video platform as big as youtube without having to pay with money or my attention.
Quick question, how were you planning to cover costs?
Aaah! So you weren’t around when YouTube was add-free for over a decade.
EDIT: it’s amazing how many people flock to defend the monetizing of YouTube and how they run their shit, yet so many people whine about how they monetized.
I wonder if they’re the same people.
Over a decade of running at a loss. That is only possible for companies, like Google, that are already very rich.
Actually that’s a quite typical time for tech start-up to break even. The whole time they’re funded by business angels.
But for some cases, the loss can be considerable, and still the “start-up” keeps finding investors. Ex: Uber, lost 30 G$ on over 14years before turning around. Or just look at all the AI pure-players companies right now.
Yes, that’s quite typical, if you manage to find a rich investor. But that only happens if you have a way to eventually make a profit. If you say from the start you’re never going to have ads or subscriptions so you’re never going to make money with this, you’re not going to find an investor.
It ran at a financial loss every year until more recently.
YouTube started with a lot of angel funding, which is why it eventually monetized in the way that it has
YouTube began as an angel-funded enterprise working from a makeshift office in a garage. In November 2005, venture firm Sequoia Capital invested an initial $3.5 million,[20] and Roelof Botha (a partner of the firm and former CFO of PayPal) joined the YouTube board of directors. In April 2006, Sequoia and Artis Capital Management invested an additional $8 million in the company, which had experienced significant growth in its first few months.
Costs that they’re now paying for with ads and subscriptions. So I’ll ask again. What would you do differently?
I don’t understand this line of thinking. A one time fee for an internet service you could potentially use for a decade? I host a number of small projects online and if I scale them way down in terms of hardware resources and don’t add a database or external services (required for basically any functionality), I’m still paying a few bucks a month. Add a database to it and it doubles. Now add a fucking crawler and your egress data rates are gonna climb quick. Not to mention the domain name itself is $12-15 a year.
A one time fee is not compatible with an online service. Ads historically have filled this gap for recurring revenue. If you don’t want ads, there’s literally no other ethical choice to make sure you can stay in business and ideally turn a small profit.
You keep mentioning YouTube was ad free, and sure. But that’s the classic Silicon Valley model. Offer a great product cheaper (ad free) than others, gain adoption, and once you have a huge user base, start to ratchet up the price. Either via ads or subscriptions. You need deep pockets and lots of VC money to make this work and ultimately you’re pulling a bit of a bait and switch on your users. Is that the model you want to support?
I’d rather, and I do, donate to apps like Blender, LibreOffice, Wikipedia, and Lemmy, etc. Free to use for people who can’t afford to donate. I donate monthly to those because I use them a lot and I can afford it.
Sounds like we’re in agreement, great. Not everything can have that scheme but I support things as best I can, again as long as it’s fair. Affordability is different for everyone.
Not all people can pay anything (myself, for example). I’m with him, and Kagi isn’t FOSS too so it’s even worst.
Things should be not only accesible, but also affordable for all.
That’s not really my point, but for what it’s worth I don’t mind if I was paying for something and it allowed you to use it because you can’t afford it.
Nothing in life is free, someone’s paying for it. If I use a service, I think it’s fair for me to pay a fair price.
I’d pay for it if their $5 a month tier wasn’t so limited
Same tbf. 5$ for 300 searches is so limited. I just checked my DDG history for the month and I average between 2500 and 3500 searches a month. I don’t even use it professionally, its just general consumer use.
Honestly I likely would pay for it if it was 5$ for 3k-4k searches. I would just swap to another engine for the remainder but, 1$/1k searches up to 10$ which moves to unlimited would be more than fine, even if they decided to remove the bloat like lens, and translation from the package. but they are likely hoping more people are not like me and will just pay the 10$ a month to have unlimited rather than just not use the service at all.
Especially considering how many other services that I get way more value of are not much more than the unlimited plan… I can have internet browsing for 10$ which i already have for free, or I can pay a couple $'s more and get a streaming service or a news site which contains content that I don’t already have access to.
I like the mentality but, it’s just not worth it for me for a non-essential service that adds nothing of value to me outside one less site harvesting my data.
Are you rephrasing searches often?
Not getting what you wanted the first time?
Because that’s a ton of queries.DDG gets to show more ads that way.
It might not be you, but part of the plan to make you run more queries.yea a lot of my searches are technical in nature so I need to reword them in order to have the right critera show. Like looking for a linux virtual display will require 3 different types of searches depending on how its phrased, and will try to show queries about vGPU setups or KVM which are not related to that type of virtual driver (but it technically could be). and sometimes it needs to be narrowed down to specifically your setup as well which adds more searches to it. Specific error codes such as CRTC errors require multiple searches until you can find the right code, gaming wikis and questions can be similar especially if its about more secretive parts of it such as easter eggs or secret endings.
Funnily I feel just the other way around ^^
Like, it’s only 10$ for something as fundamental as a search engine. It gives me way better results than any other engine I tried, and so far they kept their promise of making it better for me and not for some advertiser or data collector.
And then a streaming service wants more than that, is not as important in my daily life and chances are that the one thing I’d like to watch right now is on another service anyway.
Although I have to say, that recently I find the results not so good anymore. But I suspect that’s more to do with LLMs, because people just don’t communicate their troubleshooting anymore. So if I search “how do I get xy to work”, there’s just no quality content about it anymore, as people ask their LLM.
No one should have to pay to search the web. They’re as bad as all the other monetized bullshit.
It costs money to maintain software?
Ahh. So you’re fine with all the ads on YouTube? Two and a half minutes of commercials every 8 minutes on streaming services? Unblockable ads on websites?
No, but if you DON’T want ads then they need to get money from somewhere?
I RARELY use YouTube
I block all ads from all sites on the internet.
I pay money to the fediverse hosting foundation because hosting software costs money. I pay creators to create content because creating content costs them time and if they are going to do that thing, they need money.
Ahh. So you’re fine with all the ads on YouTube?
No, that’s why I pay for YouTube too. If I wouldn’t use it as much that the price is worth it, I would likely not use it at all (besides the irregular link thrown over my fence ever once in a while).
You’re why there are ads.
I thinks it’s all the people and companies uploading thousands of hours of video every second. I’m pretty sure that’s the reason for the ads.
tl;dr: you’re paying for search either way. A reliable and secure open-source non-profit would be better but I’d rather be paying directly than use a “free” service which extracts an opaque and invariably sinister cost in perpetuity.
No one should have to pay for anything. We have enough excess that a gift economy is entirely feasible. Convincing folks of that, creating new systems to realize the possibility, and shifting from our existing systems, are all separate and difficult tasks.
In the current system I do think an independently run organization funded by the public (likely via taxes but possibly via private donation) does make sense though. In lieu of that, or something better, there is no useful internet search without payment. Using free search engines means either someone else eats the cost (which may work for small/local communities but isn’t scalable without massive public funding and/or taxes) or the cost is subsidized a la surveillance capitalism and advertising.
Using free services run for profit extracts a cost that may be difficult to measure but there is no doubt it exists. When for-profit companies obscure that cost I am compelled to assume it is because they estimate I would not be willing to pay the asking price for their services.
Adjust this relationship to the magnitude of entire societies enveloped within, and seemingly dependent on, those services and the choice to personally decouple from that paradigm is an incredibly attractive option. I think, if one has the means, it may be ethically compelling as well (but that’s a different conversation).
I think your first sentence is a valid opinion to hold, but I disagree that they’re just as bad when they’re very upfront about what you’re paying for. Google et all meanwhile don’t make it clear that they monitize user data unless you’re paying attention
The $5 a month tier is more than enough for me; I don’t think I’ve gone over the 300 queries a month in almost a year, and I feel like I search a lot. Those couple of times I have, all it means is starting a new 30 day period a little early. It’s painless.
Does this mean it’s effectively $0.0167 per search, and you have to buy batches of 300 searches, but they have an expiration date?
Basically, yeah
I always go well over 300. I search everything

I definitley search a lot in that case; I tried it for a few months and I think I hit the 300 cap after three weeks each month.
300 searches is ten per day, they aren’t that many. Most days I think I’d do less than that but then there are days that I’m looking for something specific and might do many times that.
It is definitely not something to use instead of bookmarks like most people use google.
Yeah, if you’re hitting the search engine to bring up YouTube instead of going to the site or something, probably the $10 a month tier makes more sense.
I’d pay if it wasn’t based in the US.
Uruki presents itself as a European alternative to Kagi. They seem to have a different vision, however (no AI and just focused on a search engine). On the other hand, I didn’t try because I find the price a bit high for the little comfort it brings me, but it’s still good to test!
Kagi is European. Not in the EU: they’re based in Serbia. But they are European.
The US address that’s associated with them is just their founder’s home address.
I have never heard of that before but, they have a really weird requirement for source release.
Source code will be made available to customers who have been paying for at least 12 months.
I don’t think I’ve heard of any software doing that before,
also I really don’t like how the “how do you know we don’t track queries” is basically referring to pay them to see the source code once you hit the 12 month req.
That being said I just tried the trial account on it, it is pretty cool. I like the anonymity feel to it, even if the UI isn’t super friendly.
I was paying for Kagi and quite happy with it, but I’m gonna try Uruki for a few months since my Kagi subscription was almost coming to an end.
Then I’ll see if I stick with Uruki or go back to Kagi.
Thabks for letting us know about that product!
If you’re up for it, I’d absolutely love a mini-review/comparison, at the end of your evaluation. Or, not-so-mini, if you feel like it. Post it on Lemmy, perhaps (and remember to ping me!). :)
To be honest, I’m probably not gonna use it enough to review it. Specifically, I’m really gonna use it like a grandma so I don’t feel like it would honest to review it.
It’s as if I asked my 9 year old son to review a car😅
Hahah, that’s fair!
That sounds like how most of us would use it, though. Normal, subjective opinions can be really helpful, and a mini-review doesn’t really need anything more than that. :)
Fair point.
Same. If ecosia or qwant had subscriptions I’d probably pay for at least one of them.
I’d rather pay for the product than be the product myself and a search engine is the thing I use the most on the internet. And so I became a subscriber. Then I discovered their lens feature and now no other search engine even comes close for me on this and it’s another thing I use multiple times per day.
I would pay, for my personal use. But a lot of the time I’m on my company corp network, on a company device. And I don’t mix that with my personal logins and personal devices.
Others are saying its not new, but it is to me. Thank you for sharing OP!
I mean it can be a good share and also not be new
Which is why I commented in affirmation to be more wholesome and encourage more people to post about what new, to them, things they discover.
you can also find something similar in SearXNG
Yeah, and that one is FLOSS (Free [as in Free Beer], Libre (as in Free Speech/Freedom] and Open Source Software). So SearXNG >>>>> Kagi.
But are the results better?
No.
I tested a lot of different search engines when I was leaving Google and Kagi was the best by quite a bit. The customization features easily push it over the edge.
Yeah, at least for me
Except it still relies on closed source indexes to do anything useful, and they are actively trying to block scrapers.
Finally, I can pay money to use Lemmy
That’s fucking awesome but the ranking is highly questionable.
I searched myself and a 4 upvote comment was the top thing.
I would have expected plenty of results from lemmynsfw given your username.
That’s because 4 upvotes here is like 4k upvotes on that other site.
How many upvotes did the other results have?
56, 66, 115, 155, 156, 230, and 237
Oof.
Degoog has a Lemmy plugin
Is degoog any good?
I was self hosting searxng for a long time then after one of the updates I stopped getting results. A friend of mine told me about degoog so I switched and so far I like it. It has a lot of plugins and addons. I basically have it looking or feeling like Google used to. I was also able to incorporate my ollama instance for LLM summaries if I add a question mark in my searches.
How did you integrate ollama with it? That sounds like an interesting setup.
I’ll give it a shot, thanks!
That sounds nice i tried degood when it was first out. Seems like its gotten a lot more support now.
kagi small web lens is honestly the best thing <3
How did you get that? Mine only has the option for “forums”.
Now that’s neat
“Now has”
You mean, you just noticed a feature that has been there for awhile?






























