No, I think we agree. I also think that anything that “is trying to express something interesting to them by arranging the world to express it is pretty neat”. The thing is that most of the “modern” art doesn’t really does that. Just putting something together that doesn’t convey any idea, just “is there” doesn’t count as art for me. Like this “painting” costs $14k:
It’s just manufactured by dozens of assistants in a big workshop, slapping dots on canvases all the time. How is that “art”? If this is “art” anything designed by anyone is. Like a t-shirt from Zara is art and a bicycle is art. It doesn’t convey any ideas, it’s just worth money because a famous “artist” signed it. And modern art is full of cases like that: become famous by doing weird stunts and “going viral”, cash out by doing anything, really. It’s pointless.
I’m more lenient in my definitions maybe, but I think we do see eye to eye. I try to sidestep what constitutes “art” because it’s so often muddied to mean just whatever we approve of. So for that matter I do think art can be anything, which makes the term meaningless, which is fine by me.
But yeah someone trying to express something…weirdly is probably the best definition I can think of. Effort and intent matter as much as taste and execution imho (opinions will vary wildly).
I think what I object to more is monied art, or art that exists within the cynical gallery industrial complex. I don’t really care if art is low-effort, that’s fine, but putting a $1M pricetag on anything that is not worth that in raw materials to me is missing the point.
I know artists like to kind of play rich people, but they don’t realise how much they’ve been corrupted by their money.
No, I think we agree. I also think that anything that “is trying to express something interesting to them by arranging the world to express it is pretty neat”. The thing is that most of the “modern” art doesn’t really does that. Just putting something together that doesn’t convey any idea, just “is there” doesn’t count as art for me. Like this “painting” costs $14k:
It’s just manufactured by dozens of assistants in a big workshop, slapping dots on canvases all the time. How is that “art”? If this is “art” anything designed by anyone is. Like a t-shirt from Zara is art and a bicycle is art. It doesn’t convey any ideas, it’s just worth money because a famous “artist” signed it. And modern art is full of cases like that: become famous by doing weird stunts and “going viral”, cash out by doing anything, really. It’s pointless.
I’m more lenient in my definitions maybe, but I think we do see eye to eye. I try to sidestep what constitutes “art” because it’s so often muddied to mean just whatever we approve of. So for that matter I do think art can be anything, which makes the term meaningless, which is fine by me.
But yeah someone trying to express something…weirdly is probably the best definition I can think of. Effort and intent matter as much as taste and execution imho (opinions will vary wildly).
I think what I object to more is monied art, or art that exists within the cynical gallery industrial complex. I don’t really care if art is low-effort, that’s fine, but putting a $1M pricetag on anything that is not worth that in raw materials to me is missing the point.
I know artists like to kind of play rich people, but they don’t realise how much they’ve been corrupted by their money.