• 7 Posts
  • 2.05K Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 22nd, 2024

help-circle
  • There are endless threads to discuss in this, but two really seem lost in this debate:

    • The distinction between vibecoding, and lower levels of LLM tool usage.

    • How widespread the latter already is in software development.

    Basically, if you’re a dev coding for money… you’re already interacting with text models, somehow. You have been. Everyone reading this post is using code touched by them, up and down the stack.

    Hence I don’t think people realize how impractical the “purist anti AI” stance really is. It’s like asking devs to avoid anything touched by Microsoft or Facebook: a good idea on the surface, but how on Earth would you actually do it?

    I think what gamers really hate is higher levels of vibecoding and tool usage to make slop. As they should. As well as support for authoritarian entities backing them. But this just isn’t a practical debate without discussing where to draw the line, rather than an absolutist “LLMs or no LLMs” take, as the latter is going to catch basically every dev on the planet.


  • Not all LLM trainers are so caustic to the world. A few use open datasets for the vast majority of their training, like Nvidia’s Nemotron series or a few Olmo derivates.

    Many LLms are also trained on shoestring budgets, with a relatively negligible environmental impact.

    But are also other huge ethical concerns, like entities behind them supporting censorship, fascism and such. The erosion of the world’s mental aptitude from how it’s presented. Security, labor, hacking and spamming, and so on.


    …This is the thing with discussing “AI.”

    It can be as nuanced as things get, but few care. Most seem to want things in simple absolutist terms, and they aren’t interested in any nuance, especially the gamers on either side of this debate.











  • I have to ask… beyond the dramatic headline, what’s the big deal?

    China is doing their own thing with LLM ASICs. They have been, for some time.

    Basically all of Nvidia’s internal documentation could be leaked, and… nothing would really change, as they still have a gigantic software and silicon moat where they are applicable.

    Security could be an issue for (say) running Nvidia hardware at the DoD, but they should be protected by more layers anyway?

    There’s the implication that the CCP blackmailed this woman, but that’s not exactly unexpected. They have a long history of controlling overseas citizens, as do other countries. Obviously Jensen shouldn’t have done this, but his romantic life is his personal business.

    So what, specifically, is everyone so worried about?