Do you have a good source to read more about this? I have been searching on this what feels like half an hour and the results are not saying anything on the topic or either boil down to ‘Soviet=Communist dictatorship gulag 100 billion dead’ or ‘Your boot tastes so good comrade Stalin’
Sure, I have a few leftist commentaries on the matter I’ve cited before! Thank Marxists.org for being free and searchable, lmao, they’re a darling resource.
So I have read more on the topic but I still have some more confusions that I hope you can clear up. Firstly you said that the Bolsheviks banned the Soviets from having elections, but the sources I read just stated that they gradually lost power in favor of the of the central comitee of the CP and later the Politburo. Is this what you meant or did I overread something?. Later you talked about how they only allowed their people to be elected. Are you referring to the supreme soviet or soviets as a whole?
Firstly you said that the Bolsheviks banned the Soviets from having elections, but the sources I read just stated that they gradually lost power in favor of the of the central comitee of the CP and later the Politburo. Is this what you meant or did I overread something
Sorry, there are a lot of separate issues addressed - during the Russian Civil War, the Bolsheviks opted to refuse to seat any new representatives from the Soviets when they realized the public mood was turning against them in… either late 1918 or late 1919.
Later, when all other parties were formally banned, they graciously ‘allowed’ Soviets to elect members of the Communist Party, if they wanted.
Later you talked about how they only allowed their people to be elected. Are you referring to the supreme soviet or soviets as a whole?
All elections. There were no legal other parties after 1921, practically speaking, and independent ‘non-party’ candidates were only allowed if they were explicitly approved as individual candidates by the Communist Party - and they rarely were anything but Bolsheviks who voted in lockstep themselves.
Do you have a good source to read more about this? I have been searching on this what feels like half an hour and the results are not saying anything on the topic or either boil down to ‘Soviet=Communist dictatorship gulag 100 billion dead’ or ‘Your boot tastes so good comrade Stalin’
Sure, I have a few leftist commentaries on the matter I’ve cited before! Thank Marxists.org for being free and searchable, lmao, they’re a darling resource.
https://www.marxists.org/archive/luxemburg/1918/russian-revolution/ch04.htm
https://www.marxists.org/history/etol/writers/wright/1937/12/intnotes1.htm
https://www.marxists.org/archive/kollonta/1921/workers-opposition/intro.htm
So I have read more on the topic but I still have some more confusions that I hope you can clear up. Firstly you said that the Bolsheviks banned the Soviets from having elections, but the sources I read just stated that they gradually lost power in favor of the of the central comitee of the CP and later the Politburo. Is this what you meant or did I overread something?. Later you talked about how they only allowed their people to be elected. Are you referring to the supreme soviet or soviets as a whole?
Sorry, there are a lot of separate issues addressed - during the Russian Civil War, the Bolsheviks opted to refuse to seat any new representatives from the Soviets when they realized the public mood was turning against them in… either late 1918 or late 1919.
Later, when all other parties were formally banned, they graciously ‘allowed’ Soviets to elect members of the Communist Party, if they wanted.
All elections. There were no legal other parties after 1921, practically speaking, and independent ‘non-party’ candidates were only allowed if they were explicitly approved as individual candidates by the Communist Party - and they rarely were anything but Bolsheviks who voted in lockstep themselves.